Previous Topic: Advanced Password Services CapabilitiesNext Topic: Install and Configure APS


SiteMinder (Basic) Password Services & Advanced Password Services

Starting with Version 4.1, SiteMinder included Password Services. The functionality included is essentially a subset (with a few extensions) of the Advanced Password Services Version 1.1 functionality. Compared to APS Version 1.1, PS adds policies based on the user’s location in the Directory and removes email support and support for Windows NT user directories.

Not every site requires Advanced Password Services. For some sites, the functionality provided by Password Services is sufficient.

It should be noted that there are no utilities for converting data from PS to APS or vice versa. Each system stores its information separately; they cannot access each other’s data.

The following table compares the features of PS with this version of APS. Check with your CA Representative for current comparisons.

Feature

Basic PS (v6.0)

APS (v5.5)

Comment

Password format control

 

Minimum Length

Yes

Yes

 

Maximum Length

Yes

Yes

 

Minimum Letters

Yes

Yes

 

Minimum Uppercase Letters

Yes

Yes

 

Minimum Lowercase Letters

Yes

Yes

 

Minimum Digits

Yes

Yes

 

Minimum Alphanumeric

Yes

Yes

 

Minimum Punctuation

Yes

Yes

 

Minimum Symbols

No

Yes

 

Minimum non-alphanumeric

Yes

Yes

 

Maximum Repeat

Yes

Yes

 

Minimum Type Combinations

No

Yes

 

Complexity Thresholds

No

Yes

 

Forced case (case-insensitivity)

Yes

Yes

 

Regular Expression Match

Yes

Yes

 

Regular Expression Forbid

Yes

Yes

 

Allowed Characters List

No

Yes

 

Disallowed Characters List

No

Yes

 

Reuse Timer

Yes

Yes

 

Reuse Counter

Yes

Yes

 

Require Percentage Change

Yes

Yes

 

Prevent use of Profile Values

Yes

Yes

APS can parse words in the profile and exclude specific attributes

Directory Support (see the CA Support Site for specific vendors & versions)

 

LDAP Consumers

Yes

Yes

 

Access to all values

No

Yes

Except password history

Requires Schema mods

No

Yes

 

Exclude Accounts from

Processing

No

Yes

 

Event Handling

 

Number of Unique Events

1

7+

APS can selectively trap events

Redirect user

Yes

Yes

 

Macro substitution into URL

No

Yes

Attribute substitution as well

Vary URL by realm/user

No

Yes

 

Send Mail

No

Yes

 

Macro substitution into Mail

N/A

Yes

Attribute substitution as well

Notify of Password Change

N/A

Yes

 

Password Expiration

 

Warning before expiration

Yes

Yes

APS can send warning without requiring a user login

Password Expires

Yes

Yes

 

Grace period after expiration

No

Yes

 

Grace logins after expiration

No

Yes

 

Per-user overrides of period

No

Yes

 

Account Expiration

 

Disable at login

Yes

Yes

 

Warn days before disabling

No

Yes

 

Disable upon expiration

No

Yes

 

Disable at specific date/time

No

Yes

 

Disable if no login by date/time

No

Yes

 

Disable until specified date/time

No

Yes

 

Per-user overrides of period

No

Yes

 

Report when eligible for purge

No

Yes

 

Arbitrary Account Disable

No

Yes

With custom reason codes

"n"-strikes, you’re out processing

 

Configurable number of strikes

Yes

Yes

 

Works with LDAP outage

No

Yes

 

Automatic reset after time

Yes

Yes

 

Manual reset

Yes

Yes

 

Permanently disable account

Yes

Yes

Optional in both cases

Notify Administrator

No

Yes

Via email event/pager interface

Notify Administrator of continuing attack

No

Yes

Via email event/pager interface

Configuration

 

By location in LDAP DIT

Yes

Yes

 

By arbitrary expression

Limited

Full

 

Policies stored in

Policy Store

Flat File

 

Simple Policy Configuration

Yes

Yes

 

Cascading Policies

Yes

Yes

 

Easy migration of configuration information between environments

No

Yes

Meaning promotion from DEV to QA to Production environments by separating environment specific settings from configuration settings into separate files.

Password Change Forms

 

Languages supported

Limited

Any

 

Internationalized messages

No

Yes

 

Customized messages

No

Yes

 

User-initiated password change

Yes

Yes

 

Redirect on error

No

Yes

 

Administrator Interface

 

Supports all product features

No

Yes

 

Limit access to subsets of users

No

Yes

 

Audited

Yes

Yes

 

Can be externally accessible

No

Yes

 

Can add custom attributes

No

Yes

 

Attribute access by user

No

Yes

 

Look & Feel configurable

No

Yes

By user, if desired

Can be tied into existing apps

No

Yes

 

Tools Supplied

 

 

 

Set Force Change Flag

Yes

Yes

 

Command line change password

No

Yes

 

Other tools

None

7

 

Per User Usage Statistics

 

Available in responses

Limited

Yes

 

Last Login Date

Available in responses

Yes

Includes IP address

Previous Login Date

Available in responses

Yes

Optional. Includes IP address

Last Password Change Date

No

Yes

 

Last Failure Date

No

Yes

Optional. Includes IP address

Login History

No

Yes

Optional. Includes IP address

Failures since last login

No

Yes

Optional. Includes IP address

Failures since previous login

No

Yes

Optional. Includes IP address

Max failures between logins

No

Yes

Optional

Total Logins

No

Yes

Optional

Total Failures

No

Yes

Optional

Forgotten Password Usage

No

Yes

Optional

Forgotten Password Support

 

Included with package

No

Yes

 

User-selected password

N/A

Yes

 

Automatically login at end

N/A

Yes

 

Lockout with Counter

N/A

Yes

 

Sample Forms

N/A

Yes

 

Consumable questions

N/A

Yes

 

One-use passwords

N/A

Yes

 

Secure new password delivery

N/A

Yes

 

Encrypted/hashed answers

N/A

Yes

 

Sample forms provided

N/A

asp/jsp

 

SiteMinder Integration

 

Policy Server different from Web Agent’s Policy Server

No

Yes

 

Failover Policy Servers

Yes

Yes

 

Round-robin Policy Servers

Yes

Yes

 

Configured through Policy GUI

Yes

No

 

Integrates with DMS2

Yes

Yes

 

 

Application Programming

Interface

 

Limited

Yes

 

Miscellaneous

 

Custom Logging

No

Yes

Source provided

Custom Extensions

No

Yes

 

Disabled groups

No

Yes

 

Redirect at first/next login

No

Yes

 

Message of the Day Service

No

Yes